By ASHOK SHARMA / AP WRITER
NEW DELHI — An Indian juvenile court on Saturday handed down the
first conviction in the fatal gang rape of a young woman on a moving New
Delhi bus, convicting a teenager of rape and murder and sentencing him
to three years in a reform home, lawyers said.
The victim’s parents denounced the sentence, which was the maximum
the defendant faced. The family had long insisted the teen, who was 17
at the time of the December attack and is now 18, be tried as an
adult—and thus face the death penalty—insisting he was the most brutal
of the woman’s attackers.
“He should be hanged irrespective of whether he is a juvenile or not.
He should be punished for what he did to my daughter,” the victim’s
mother, Asha Devi, told reporters after the verdict was announced.
Indian law forbids the publication of the teen’s name because he was sentenced in a juvenile court.
The attack, which left the 23-year-old victim with such extensive
internal injuries that she died two weeks later, sparked protests across
the country and led to reforms of India’s antiquated sexual violence
laws. The government, facing immense public pressure, had promised swift
justice in the case.
The convicted teen was one of six people accused of tricking the
woman and her male companion into boarding an off-duty bus Dec. 16 after
they had seen an afternoon showing of “Life of Pi” at an upscale
shopping mall. Police say the men raped the woman and used a metal bar
to inflict massive internal injuries to her. They also beat her
companion. The victims were dumped naked on the roadside, and the woman
later died from her injuries in a Singapore hospital.
The victim’s father said the family was deeply disappointed with the sentence.
“This is completely unacceptable to us,” Badrinath Singh said. “We
are not satisfied with this outcome. He is virtually being set free.
This is very wrong.”
“No family should have a daughter if this is the fate that lies ahead
for women. In this country, it is crime to be born a girl,” he said.
Indian law forbids the publication of the names of rape victims, even if they die.
S.K. Singh, a lawyer for the victim’s family, said they would challenge the juvenile court’s verdict in a higher court.
“We will also seek a review of the man’s age by a medical panel,
since we believe he was not a juvenile when the incident took place,” he
In India, especially in rural areas, many people do not have their
births properly registered, and school certificates are used as proof of
Singh and the defendant’s lawyer, Rajesh Tewari, both confirmed the conviction and sentence.
Reporters were not allowed inside the courtroom. Scores of television
crews lined up on the road outside the court building beginning early
Saturday, waiting for the verdict.
Four of the other defendants are being tried in a special fast-track
court in New Delhi and face the death penalty. The sixth accused was
found dead in his jail cell in March. The court is expected to hand down
the rest of the verdicts in September.
The convicted defendant was tried as a minor on charges including
murder and rape. The time he has spent in a juvenile home since he was
arrested in December will count toward his sentence, Tewari said.
The attack set off furious protests across India about the treatment
of women in the country and led to an overhaul of sexual assault laws.
A government panel set to suggest reforms to sexual assault laws
rejected calls to lower the age at which people can be tried as adults
from 18 to 16.
In July, India’s top court also refused to reduce the age of a
juvenile from 18 to 16 years. However, it later agreed to hear a new
petition seeking to take the “mental and intellectual maturity” of the
defendant into account, and not just age.